And so began our family's obsession with the show's star, Ina Garten ... is where things took a turn for the worse. Garten's buttercream-meringue frosting was a ridiculous chore from start ...

The cookie mirrors the texture of cake, but the key to a delicious black and white cookie is its frosting. After all, the half-chocolate, half-vanilla ... celebrity chef Ina Garten employs one ...