When Carey told Kimmel he’s hosted 3,317 episodes of The Price Is Right since joining the show in 2007, the late-night host retorted, “Bob Barker’s 6,731.” “Yeah, I’ve got a ways to go,” Carey said. “You’re almost halfway there; you only have to do 18 more years,” Kimmel quipped.

Kimmel asked if there were any prizes that he didn’t want to give away, and Carey had his answer ready to go. “There was one prize that bugged me the first season, we would give away a grandfather clock every show,” he said.